Pakistan Case Lawโ† Search
2003 C.L.R. 1221

Nusrat Bibi & 3 others vs Naila Hanif & 2 others

Citation2003 C.L.R. 1221
CourtLahore High Court
Case No.Writ Petition No. 1130 of 2003
Date2003-04-24
Judge(s)Fakhar-un-Nisa Khokhar
ResultPetitions Dismissed in limine

ORDER

MRS. FAKHAR-UN-NISA KHOKHAR, J.--- Brief facts in this writ petition are that an eviction petition was filed by the land-ladies against the respondents in respect of shop No. 12-D Commercial Peoples Colony, Faisalabad that this shop was transferred to them by their father. Property was under tenancy of respondents who stopped paying rent to them, therefore, the eviction petition was filed which was decided on 26.1.1985 in favour of the petitioners. Appeal was filed, which was accepted vide judgment and decree dated 20.7.1986. A writ petition was filed in the Lahore High Court and during pendency of same an agreement was executed between the petitioners and predecessors-in-interest of the respondents that the rent will be Rs.1,750/- per month to be enhanced according to law and tenancy will be from 1.1.1991 till 30.12.1998 and possession will be handed over to the petitioners. The respondents have committed default and the possession is not handed over to the petitioners, therefore, eviction petition was filed on 11.1.2000. This petition was contested.

2. In the present writ petition the precise grievance of the petitioners is that the husband of Mst.

Naila has placed a special attorney on the file and he appeared as a witness and when they objected during his appearance as a witness he stated that although his special power-of- attorney is on the file but he Is appearing in his on capacity as an independent witness. An application was filed to rule out the evidence of the witness and restrain the landlady to appear as her on witness. The learned Rent Controller vide order dated 4.1.2003 dismissed the application while observing that Mian Muhammad Awais has appeared in the Court only as a witness and no embargo can be placed upon the petitioner to appear as her on witness. This order is impugned in the instant writ petition.

3. Arguments advanced by learned counsel for the petitioners are that person who has placed a special power-of attorney on the record cannot appear as an independent witness and the petitioner who has attorney to her special attorney cannot appear and give evidence.

4. I have heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and perused the record. A careful perusal of special power-of attorney Ex. R-1 shows that special attorney is delegated with the powers to engage a counsel in the eviction petition, to pursue the eviction petition, to draw the rent already submitted by the tenant, to file an appeal or revision but it never delegated the power to special attorney to appear and give statement in evidence on behalf of the landladies therefore, the arguments advanced by learned counsel for the petitioners are not convincing and "Qamar Zaman v. Municipal Corporation, Mirpur, etc." (PLD 2001 S.C. (Aj&K) 18) is not applicable to this case.

Even this judgment gives observation to the construction of power-of-attorney that general rule of construction of power-of-attorney is that it must be construed strictly giving only such authority as expressly conferred or by necessary implication. When no authority is given to the person who is holder of special attorney to appear and give statement on behalf of the petitioners he has specifically debarred to do so and he has rightly admitted in his cross-examination that he is appearing as an independent witness on behalf of the petitioners. It is rightly observed by the learned Trial Court that learned Rent Controller cannot restrain a party to appear as his or her witness when no delegation of power is given to any one to make a statement on their behalf, therefore, finding no substance in the instant writ petition the same is dismissed in limine.

For educational and research use only โ€” not legal advice. Verify against the official report before relying on it. See our Disclaimer.
DisclaimerยทPrivacyยทTermsยทSearch