Pakistan Case Law← Search
1998 SCMR 266

MUHAMMAD SAFDAR vs WATER AND POWER DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY

Citation1998 SCMR 266
CourtSupreme Court of Pakistan
Case No.Civil Petition No,639-L of 1995 Appeal No,21/6 of 1995
Date1996-12-08
Judge(s)Mukhtar Ahmed Junejo, Zia Mahmood Mirza
ResultLeave granted

ORDER

' ZIA MAHMOOD MIRZA, J.---Petitioner was served with a charge-sheet dated 21-1-1993 alleging that he had received illegal gratification from the residents of Mauza Kakey Zayan and had also drawn excessive material from store by preparing wrong estimates. He assailed the validity of this charge-sheet before N.I.R.C. A learned Member of the N.I.R.C. By an ex parte order dated 21-2-1993 set aside the charge-sheet. WAPDA moved an application before the N.I.R.C. For recalling the ex parte order dated 21-2-1993. It appears that the learned Member of N.I.R.C. Suspended the operation of his ex parte order dated 21-2-1993 on 15-11-1994 but ultimately application of WAPDA for setting aside the ex parte order was dismissed vide order dated 17-5-1995. It, however, appears that notwithstanding the fact that the charge-sheet in question was earlier set aside by N.I.R.C., WAPDA had been holding the proceedings pursuant to that charge-sheet and finally by an order dated 26-5-1994 dismissed the petitioner from service. Petitioner challenged his dismissal from service in an appeal before the Service Tribunal but with no better result as his appeal has been dismissed vide the impugned judgment.

2. We have heard the learned counsel for the petitioner as also the learned counsel appearing for the respondent/cavcator. Former has contended, inter alia, that the charge-sheet on the basis whereof petitioner was dismissed from service having been set aside by a learned Member of N.I.R.C. On 21-2-1993, all the proceedings taken and the dismissal order passed on the basis of allegations made in that charge-sheet were of no legal effect. Contention raised needs consideration. Leave to appeal is accordingly granted to the petitioner.

For educational and research use only — not legal advice. Verify against the official report before relying on it. See our Disclaimer.
Disclaimer·Privacy·Terms·Search