Pakistan Case Law← Search
1975 SCMR 203

MESSRS BUNDIAL BUS SERVICEs vs Mst. SANJEEDA AFZAL AND OTHERS

Citation1975 SCMR 203
CourtSupreme Court of Pakistan
Case No.Civil Petition for Special Leave to Appeal No, 789 of 1974
Date1974-11-08
Judge(s)Abdul Qadir Sheikh, Muhammad Yaqub Ali Khan
ResultPetition dismissed

1. ' ABDUL KADIR SHAIKH, J.-This is a petition for special leave to appeal from an order of a Division Bench of the Lahore High Court refusing to stay execution of decree passed against the petitioners herein pending disposal of their appeal. The decree was passed on 20th March, 1973 for payment of Rs, 1,57,000 as damages and compensation on account of accident, by rash and negligent act, in which Khawaja Muhammad Afzal, husband of respondent No, 1 and father of respondents 2 to 5 was killed. Khawaja Muhammad Afzal at the time he met his death by accident was posted as Executive Engineer (Irrigation) Kalabagh Division, District Mian wali.

2. High Court has held that there is "no case for stay" and "thus depriving the decree-holders of the fruit of the decree". It has, however, been directed that the decretal amount, if deposited in Court, shall not be paid to the decree-holders, unless sufficient security for re-imbursement is furnished by them.

3. We find that High Court has exercised its discretion on sound principles of law governing execution of money decrees pending their challenge on appeal. Decree-holders lost their bread-winner long ago, on 31st January, 1968. And it is only proper that they should reap fruits of the decree passed in their favour, rather than just have a "paper-decree" to console themselves for the time-being. The interest of petitioners has also been adequately safe-guarded in the eventuality of their success in appeal in the High Court.

4. ' There is, therefore, no merit in this petition. It is dismissed.

For educational and research use only — not legal advice. Verify against the official report before relying on it. See our Disclaimer.
Disclaimer·Privacy·Terms·Search