Pakistan Case Law← Search
1992 CLC 2350

ASH RAF BIBI and others vs LAHORE MUNICIPAL CORPORATION and others

Citation1992 CLC 2350
CourtLahore High Court
Case No.F.A.O, No, 286 of 1980
Date1992-04-14
Judge(s)Munir A. Sheikh
ResultAppeal accepted

' This appeal is directed against the order dated 13-10-1980 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Lahore, through which the application filed by the appellants before the said Court for re-admission of appeal dismissed for non-prosecution on 15-3-1975 has been rejected.

2. The record which is available has been perused. The appeal of the appellants was dismissed on 15-3-1975. According to the record the case was called and nobody appeared on behalf of the appellants, therefore, the same was dismissed for default.

3. Application for re-admission of the appeal was submitted on the same day. The reason given in the application was that the appellants' learned counsel had gone to some other Court to attend other cases and when he came back the appeal had already been dismissed for non-prosecution.

4. The learned lower Appellate Court took the view that no affidavit was attached with the application to support the plea raised in the application and also that no reason was given which prevented the appellants to appear before the Court when the case was called. I am afraid the learned lower Appellate Court has taken too technical view of the matter. It has altogether been ignored that the application was submitted on the same day promptly. The Court time was up to 4-00 p.m., therefore, the haste in dismissal of appeal was not called for which could be kept in waiting till the closing hours of the day. The law favours adjudication of the rights of the parties on merits rather than disposal of the same in a summary manner. The order under appeal is not sustainable, as the learned lower Appellate Court acted highly arbitrarily in the matter of exercise of discretion in the matter which has resulted in miscarriage of justice and failure to adjudicate the rights of the appellants.

5. This appeal is accepted. Order dated 13-10-1980 is set aside. The application moved by the appellants for re-admission of appeal is accepted and the appeal re-admitted. The case is sent back to the learned lower Appellate Court for disposal of appeal on merits. There will be no order as to costs.

Cited by 1 case

For educational and research use only — not legal advice. Verify against the official report before relying on it. See our Disclaimer.
Disclaimer·Privacy·Terms·Search