Pakistan Case Lawโ† Search
1973 PLC 44

MESSRS GUEST KEEN & NETTLEFOLDS IN PAKISTAN Ltd., KARACHI vs WORKERS

Citation1973 PLC 44
CourtLabour Appellate Tribunal
Case No.Miscellaneous Application No. 12,7 of 1972
Date1972-07-16
Judge(s)Shafi Muhammad R. Ahmad
Resultapplication is stayed

ORDER

1. In this application under Order XXXIX, rule 4, C. P. C., the applicants seek setting aside the order of Ad interim Injunction granted to the respondent-Union by this Court on 13th June 1972.

2. The Ad interim Injunction was granted, as the result of an application moved by the respondent- Union, restraining the applicants from dismissing, discharging, retrenching, laying off or terminating the services of the members of the respondent-Union on any account including closure of business or re-organisation, during rte pendency of their application under section 34 of the Industrial Relations Ordinance, 1969.

3. The case of the applicants in this application, as well as in the previous one is that, on account of the loss of market in East to Pakistan and reduction of sales in West Pakistan, there has been accumulation of stock worth Rs. 16 lakhs. Consequently, they W are contemplating re-organisation of their business as the result of which they will have to retrench surplus staff to the extent of 63 workers from service. They further state that the workers have resorted to organised go-slow, both before and after the n order of Ad interim Injunction, causing further financial loss to their business.

4. Since the applicants cannot take any action against-- them on account of the Ad interim Injunction they have moved this application for setting it aside.

5. The respondent-Union have pleaded, inter alia, that the applicants have also tiled an appeal against the order of Ad interim injunction, which is pending before the Sind Labour Appellate Tribunal. The Representative for the applicants, while admitting that an appeal is pending, states that there is no specific bar for filing the present application on account of the pending appeal. I am afraid with this contention of the learned Re--presentative I am unable to agree. He cannot seek the same remedy in two forums at the same time, which may result into conflicting decisions.

6. The principle laid down in section 10 of the Civil Procedure Coda clearly applies in the present case.

7. Consequently, the present application is stayed till the decision of the appeal.

For educational and research use only โ€” not legal advice. Verify against the official report before relying on it. See our Disclaimer.
DisclaimerยทPrivacyยทTermsยทSearch