Pakistan Case Law← Search
1984 SCMR 1248

MUHAMMAD ANWAR and others vs MUHAMMAD ASHRAF and others

Citation1984 SCMR 1248
CourtSupreme Court of Pakistan
Case No.Civil Petition No, 145 of 1982 R.F.A. No,200 of 1981
Date1984-02-05
Judge(s)Nasim Hasan Shah, M. S. H. Qureshi
ResultLeave granted

ORDER

' M.S.H. QURAISHI, J.-- The petitioners, who are vendees/heirs of vendees, filed Regular First Appeal in the High Court against the decree passed against them by the trial Court in a pre-emption suit. As many as ten issues had been framed and decided in regard to the controversy between the parties, of which the findings on issues Nos. 1,2, 9 and 10 had been specifically challenged in the memorandum of appeal. However, the appeal was admitted only "to consider the question of appellants' entitlement to compensation for the improvements alleged to have been effected by them". The High Court also did not allow them any interim relief in regard to the possession of the disputed land for the reason that "the appellants have to part with the disputed land in any case".

2. Although the petitioners' appeal is pending in the High Court, learned counsel has sought leave to appeal urging that the admitting order amounted to dismissal of their appeal in regard to their pleas other than that of compensation for the improvements, that the High Court had not assigned any reason for such dismissal and that, therefore, the dismissal of the appeal on those other pleas was bad in law. Reliance was placed on Eswariah v. Rameswaryya AIR 1940 Mad. 483, Muhammad Saghir Bhatti & Sons v. Federation of Pakistan PLD 1958 SC 221 and Abid Hussain v. Afsar Jehan Begum PLD 1973 SC 1.

3. The point raised requires consideration. Leave to appeal is accordingly granted. Security Rs,2,500.

The appeal shall be heard in the week commencing 24th March, 1984 at Rawalpindi. The stay already granted shall continue to remain in force.

For educational and research use only β€” not legal advice. Verify against the official report before relying on it. See our Disclaimer.
DisclaimerΒ·PrivacyΒ·TermsΒ·Search