Pakistan Case Law← Search
1982 SCMR 1196

BEGUM ALMAS DAULTANA vs MANZOOR AHMAD KHAN AND Other

Citation1982 SCMR 1196
CourtSupreme Court of Pakistan
Case No.Civil Petition No. 247 of 1979
Date1981-11-09
Judge(s)Nasim Hasan Shah, Karam Elahi Chauhan
ResultPetition dismissed

ORDER

1. NASIM HASSAN SHAH, J.-This petition is directed against the judgment of a learned Single Judge of the Lahore High Court dated 14-1-1979, whereby the writ petition (W. P. No, 1119-R/70), filed by Respondent No. 1 herein, was accepted and the judgment of the Settlement Commissioner elated 9-7-1970 was declared to be without lawful and the Chief Settlement Commissioner directed to entrust the case to a competent officer to decide it afresh according to law. We have heard Mr. Zaki-ud-Din P.1, in support of this petition, as well as Mr. Dilawar Mahmood on behalf of Respondent No. 1, examined the documents filed by them in support of their respective contentions and care-- fully perused the judgment of the High Court and have come to the conclu--sion that the matter did require further examination and the order of remand to the competent officer to decide it afresh according to law was justified and is not open to any objection.

2. We, however, find that while remanding the case for decision afresh, the learned Judge in the High Court has made certain strong observations, which could conceivably influence the competent officer while deciding this matter afresh. We would clarify that the observations made in the judgment of the High Court must be treated in the nature of tentative observations and the officer dealing with the matter in remand will proceed to decide it uninfluenced by the said observations purely on the merits of the case in the light of the contentions advanced before him on the basis of material adduced in support thereof.

3. The petition; subject to the above observations stands dismissed.

For educational and research use only β€” not legal advice. Verify against the official report before relying on it. See our Disclaimer.
DisclaimerΒ·PrivacyΒ·TermsΒ·Search