Pakistan Case Law← Search
2011 P Cr. L J 1454

HAZOOR BUX and 5 others vs S.I.O. POLICE STATION KHANPUR MAHAR and 3

Citation2011 P Cr. L J 1454
CourtSindh High Court
Case No.Constitutional Petition No. D-2315 of 2010
Date2011-03-03
Judge(s)Faisal Arab, Tufail H. Ibrahim
ResultOrder accordingly

ORDER

Through this petition, petitioner seeks quashment of F.I.R. No.151 of 2010 registered with Police Station Khanpur Mahar under sections 118, 143, 120-B, P.P.C. During pendency of this petition, challan has been. Submitted. This Court put specific question to the counsel for petitioner that in view of the fact that challan has already been submitted petitioner may seek remedy before the trial Court.

2. Learned counsel argued that in view of the decision reported in 2000 SCM R 122 this court can quash -the proceedings if there is no probability that the accused could be convicted on the material that has come on record.

3. Mr. Zulfiqar Ali Sangi, learned State Counsel has argued that in the case of Muhammad Abbassi.v. SHO Bara Kahu and 7 others reported in PLD 2010 SC 969 where three Judges of Hon'ble Supreme Court have held that when the challan has been submitted and cognizance has been taken by the trial Court then there is alternate remedy under section 249-A, Cr.P.C. Which is more efficacious, appropriate and beneficial and the question of guilt or innocence could not be decided in the exercise of constitutional jurisdiction as such function falls within the jurisdictional domain of the court concerned before which the entire evidence is to be scrutinized which cannot be done in exercise of constitutional jurisdiction. Learned State Counsel also relied in the case of Haji Sardar Khalid Saleem v. Muhammad Ashraf and others reported in 2006 SCM R 1192.

4. As the judgment of the Supreme Court is binding on us. We are of the view that let the matter be decided by the trial Court. We, however; direct the trial Court to decide quashment application within a period of three weeks from today. Let such application be filed within three days.

With these directions, this petition stands disposed of.

For educational and research use only — not legal advice. Verify against the official report before relying on it. See our Disclaimer.
Disclaimer·Privacy·Terms·Search