Pakistan Case Law← Search
NLR 2010 Criminal 236

1. MUHAMMAD AZEEM 2. MUNEER AHMED vs THE STATE

CitationNLR 2010 Criminal 236
CourtSindh High Court
Case No.Crl. Misc. Application No, 237 of 2006
Date2007-01-08
Judge(s)Syed Zawwar Hussain Jaffery
ResultProceedings Quashed

ORDER

1. ' SYED ZAWWAR HUSSAIN JAFFERI, J.---I _intend to dispose of Cr. Misc. Applications Nos. 237/2006 to 249/2006 by common order as the applicants/accused have been falsely involved in the FIR No, 619/2006 to 632/2006 except FIR No, 631/2006 under sections 3(2)(a)(b), 13/14 of the Foreigners Act, registered at P.S. FIA Passport Cell Karachi.

2. ' The brief facts of the case disclosed in the FIR are that the applicants are the driver and conductor respectively of Bus CH-12710 of Mullah Jan Coach Service, being plied on the route Karachi to Mand.

3. Bilo. The FIA party headed by S.I. Syed Zahid All alongwith other staff intercepted the Bus and arrested the applicants and the passengers and seized the bus. The applicants and other passengers were brought at FIA Centre Karachi and 17 FIRs were registered at the P.S. FIA Passport Cell Karachi. After usual investigation the prosecution has submitted charge-sheets/challans in the Court of 4th Judicial Magistrate West Karachi. The said cases were transferred in the Court of learned Sessions Judge, Karachi West and at present the cases are pending trial in the Court of learned 1st Additional Sessions Judge West Karachi against the applicants.

4. ' It is, inter alia, contended by Mr. Mehmood A. Qureshi learned counsel for applicants that applicants are Pakistani National and they have not contravened any provision of Foreigners Act as they have neither abetted nor attempted to abet any person in contravention of any provision of any law and have not provided any assistance to the passengers in any manners either to enter Pakistan or to exit the Pakistan in contravention of any law for the time being in force. The applicants are plying the bus from Karachi to Mand Billo, therefore, the applicants are not required to ask any person to show them any travelling documentation. The applicants had not committed any offence and the FIRs registered against them is illegal and without jurisdiction. The FIA personnel has wrongly seized the said bus from the lawful custody of the applicants and arrested them in 17 FIRs with mala fide intention and ulterior motive. It is further urged that there is no evidence brought on record against the applicants except the statement of co-accused before FIA authority, which is inadmissible in law. It is further urged that no useful purpose will be served in framing the charge against the applicants as there is no evidence at all against them.

5. ' Mr. S. Mehmood Alam Rizvi learned Standing Counsel for the Federation has rightly conceded that there is no evidence against applicants as all other FIRs have been registered against applicants under the Emigration Ordinance of the same incident.

6. Admittedly, the applicants being Pakistani National have not contravened any provision of the Foreigners Act in their evidence not abetted nor attempted to abet any person in contravention of any provision of any law and have not provided any assistance to the passengers in any manners either to enter Pakistan or to exit the Pakistan in contravention of any law.

7. ' I have heard learned counsel for the respective parties.

8. ' Learned Standing Counsel has rightly urged that the proceedings pending against applicants arising out of FIRs Nos. 619/2006 to 632/2006 except FIR No, 631/2006 registered at P.S. FIA Passport Cell under sections 3(2)(a)(b), 13/14 of the Foreigners Act, are quashed, as the same were registered without lawful authority and it falls within abuse of process of the Court, Y therefore, Cr.

9. Misc. Applications Nos. 237/2006 to 249/2006 are allowed. The applicants may be released, if not detained in any other case.

For educational and research use only β€” not legal advice. Verify against the official report before relying on it. See our Disclaimer.
DisclaimerΒ·PrivacyΒ·TermsΒ·Search